When making smart investment choices throughout one’s life, the outcome is a comprehensive retirement plan. However, it can be challenging to determine the appropriate retirement account to set up due to the abundance of options available. Various types of retirement accounts, such as IRAs (individual retirement accounts), 401(k)s, Roth IRAs, pensions, and others, exist. This can often be perplexing, but it is wise to prioritize accounts that are applicable to specific business circumstances.
A self-directed IRA, whether a traditional or Roth IRA, permits individuals and businesses to possess various assets, such as alternative assets, real estate, privately traded stock, and even farming businesses. It maintains the same tax treatment and contribution regulations as a traditional or Roth IRA.
When choosing a custodian or broker to work with for self-directed IRAs, it is crucial to find the right one since these accounts can hold unconventional assets. This post will assess the top 8 brokerages, such as Pensco and Equity Trust, for self-directed IRAs. Self-directed IRAs have distinct regulations and rules compared to traditional accounts and offer higher risk-reward ratios. By including riskier assets like private company stock or horse businesses, individuals can experience greater potential gains but also a higher likelihood of losses. This guide will delve into the intricacies of self-directed IRAs, determining their suitability, and identifying the optimal broker for specific assets.
What Is a Self-Directed IRA (SDIRA)?
A self-directed individual retirement account (SDIRA) is an individual retirement account (IRA) that permits different alternative investments that are typically not allowed in regular IRAs. Despite being administered by a custodian or trustee, the account is managed directly by the account holder, hence the term “self-directed”.
Self-directed IRAs, which can be either traditional (where tax-deductible contributions are made) or Roth (where tax-free distributions can be taken), are most appropriate for knowledgeable investors seeking to diversify in a tax-advantaged account with alternative investments.
Understanding a Self-Directed IRA (SDIRA)
The types of investments that can be held in an SDIRA are the main distinction from other IRAs. Common securities such as stocks, bonds, CDs, and mutual or ETFs are typically limited to regular IRAs.
SDIRAs offer the owner the opportunity to invest in a wider range of assets. By having an SDIRA, one can possess precious metals, commodities, private placements, limited partnerships, tax lien certificates, real estate, and various alternative investments.
The account owner needs to show more initiative and due diligence when dealing with an SDIRA.
Taxes, Withdrawals, and Contributions
The maximum annual contribution to a self-directed IRA is limited. In 2023, those under age 50 can contribute up to $6,500, while individuals over 50 can make an additional catch-up contribution of $1,000.
If you decide to make withdrawals before reaching the age of 59½, you will be required to pay regular income taxes based on your income level. Additionally, a 10% penalty will be imposed and income tax will be levied on the withdrawal.
Once you reach the age of 73, it is mandatory for the IRS that you initiate the process of making withdrawals. The minimum amount that you withdraw should adhere to specific criteria which consider your account balance as well as your life expectancy.
How to Open an SDIRA
To open an SDIRA, you’ll need to go through most IRA providers and can only open a regular IRA (traditional or Roth) and invest solely in stocks, bonds, and mutual funds/ETFs.
- Find a qualified IRA custodian that specializes in SDIRAs.
- Determine whether they offer the range of investments you want.
- Set up the account and pay any fees.
- Begin contributing to your account.
Because SDIRAs are self-directed, custodians are not permitted to provide financial advice, so traditional brokerages, banks, and investment companies typically do not offer them to their clients. Therefore, it is essential to conduct thorough research on your own. If you require assistance in selecting or managing your investments, it is advisable to collaborate with a financial advisor.
Traditional vs. Roth SDIRA
When setting up a self-directed IRA, it is important to consider that it can be either a traditional or a Roth IRA. It is worth noting that these two types of accounts have varying tax treatments, eligibility requirements, contribution guidelines, and distribution rules.
The main distinction between a traditional IRA and a Roth IRA lies in the timing of tax payment. Traditional IRAs offer an initial tax benefit, but taxes are owed on both contributions and earnings when they are withdrawn in retirement. On the other hand, contributions to a Roth IRA do not provide a tax break, but both contributions and earnings accumulate without tax and qualified distributions are also tax-free.
Here’s a brief summary to consider, considering there are other differences as well.
- Income limits: Traditional IRAs have no income limits, but you must make less than a certain amount to open or contribute to a Roth.8
- Required minimum distributions (RMDs): You must start taking RMDs at age 73 if you have a traditional IRA.6 Roth IRAs have no RMDs during your lifetime.9
- Early withdrawals: With Roth IRAs, you can withdraw your contributions (but not your earnings) at any time, for any reason, with no tax or penalty. Withdrawals are tax and penalty-free after age 59½, provided the account is at least five years old. With traditional IRAs, withdrawals are penalty free starting at age 59½. Remember, you have to pay taxes on traditional IRA withdrawals.710
The same rules apply to whichever version of a Self-Directed Individual Retirement Account (SDIRA) you have, regardless of the specific variant.
Who needs a self-directed IRA?
Investors who desire greater diversification and higher returns may find self-directed IRAs to be a prudent option. This account allows investors to explore alternative choices if they are dissatisfied with investing solely in individual stocks, bonds, and ETFs. However, it is important to note that self-directed IRA users should possess a higher level of financial acumen than the average person due to the associated risk involved.
A real estate wholesaler is a type of person who would require a self-directed IRA. Wholesaling is a unique form of real estate investment where the wholesaler purchases undervalued properties from sellers facing distress. Such distressed sellers, often dealing with situations like bankruptcy or divorce, prioritize quick home sales and are open to accepting lower terms. This flexibility in negotiations enables the wholesaler to easily procure the properties.
The contract is assigned by the wholesaler to a real estate investor, who may wish to renovate and sell the house. The second investor is commonly known as a “flipper” because their aim is to repair and sell undervalued properties for a financial gain.
This example will provide a clearer understanding of wholesaling and flipping.
Wholesaler A purchases a home from couple B for $100,000, despite the property’s actual value of $150,000, as the couple requires a quick sale.
The $5,000 down payment can be made with a self-directed IRA by the wholesaler.
Next, the wholesaler proceeds to sell the property to a flipper, amounting to $125,000.
The intention of the person who flips houses is to repair and sell this property for a price equal to or higher than its market value of $150,000.
Finally, the wholesaler’s net profit amounts to $20,000, derived from subtracting $105,000 from $125,000.
Wholesalers and real estate investors could benefit from utilizing a self-directed IRA as it enables them to save for a down payment on a tax-deferred or after-tax basis. Additionally, by having the IRA own the property or wholesale fee, these investors can enjoy advantageous tax treatment.
Investing in an SDIRA
Self-directed Roth IRAs broaden the possibilities for investments by including assets that are not usually found in traditional retirement portfolios, in addition to the usual options like stocks, bonds, cash, money market funds, and mutual funds.
In your SDIRA account, you have the option to purchase investment real estate. Additionally, you can retain partnerships, tax liens, and even a franchise business.
The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) prohibits certain investments in SDIRAs, regardless of whether it is a Roth or traditional SDIRA. Examples of these prohibited investments include holding life insurance, S corporation stocks, any investment that involves self-dealing, and collectibles.
A variety of items are categorized as collectibles, including antiques, artwork, alcoholic beverages, baseball cards, memorabilia, jewelry, stamps, and rare coins. Please note that this impacts the type of gold that can be held in a self-directed Roth IRA.
Advantages and Disadvantages of SDIRAs
While SDIRAs offer numerous advantages, it is important to be mindful of a few potential pitfalls.
You have the freedom to select the assets you wish to include in the account.
Tax benefits on income
Diversity that is tailored to individuals
It is easy to unintentionally break a rule and share the complete account.
It is not possible to receive assistance from a custodian.
A fee structure that is intricate and complex.
There are certain investments that lack liquidity.
It is easy to fall prey to fraudulent activities.
Advantages Explained
- You can choose the assets you place in the account: An SDIRA allows you to select the investments you want, so if you prefer specific types of assets, sectors, or industries, you can build your portfolio to match.1
- Tax breaks on earnings: Earnings grow in the account, so you pay taxes on earnings only when you make withdrawals.1
- Personalized diversity: Choice allows you to diversify holdings within your IRA and use your IRA in your overall investing strategy to diversify your portfolio further.
Disadvantages Explained
- Easy to accidentally violate a rule and distribute the entire account: If you break a rule, the entire account could be considered distributed to you. And you’ll be on the hook for all the taxes plus a penalty. Make sure you understand and follow the rules for the specific assets that you hold in the account.
- You can’t get help from a custodian: Again, SDIRA custodians can’t offer financial advice. You’re on your own. Make sure you do your homework and find a good financial advisor if you need help.
- Complicated fee structure: SDIRAs have a complex fee structure. Typical charges include a one-time establishment fee, a first-year annual fee, an annual renewal fee, and fees for investment bill paying. These costs add up and can certainly cut into your earnings.
- Some investments are not very liquid: It’s easy to get out of stocks, bonds, and mutual funds. Just place a sell order with your broker, and the market takes care of the rest. Not so with some SDIRA investments. For example, if your SDIRA owns an apartment building, it will take some time to find the right buyer. That can be especially problematic if you have a traditional SDIRA and need to start taking distributions.
- Easy to become a victim of fraud: Even though SDIRA custodians can’t offer financial advice, they will make certain investments available. The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) notes that SDIRA custodians don’t typically evaluate “the quality or legitimacy of any investment in the self-directed IRA or its promoters.”1
Best Self-Directed IRAs (2023)
IRA Financial
A custodian with a special tax twist
IRA Financial, founded by tax professionals, is relatively new in comparison to other custodians featured on this list. It specializes in alternative assets and stands out by offering distinctive services, such as IRS audit protection. Additionally, it differentiates itself by providing not only audit protection but also comprehensive online educational resources and check writing capabilities.
uDirect IRA
Specializes in domestic real estate investments and offers check writing services
If real estate investors are seeking greater control, uDirect IRA can be an excellent choice as an IRA provider. This brokerage provides the option of check writing, enabling investors to have more authority over investment activities and potentially reduce fees. While investors are free to select any self-directed assets approved by the IRS, uDirect IRA specializes in a wide range of real estate options such as real estate notes, private loans, and tax lien certificates. Moreover, uDirect IRA offers expedited access to funds, which proves advantageous for purchasing auctioned real estate and tax lien certificates.
Charles Schwab
A household broker that offers additional banking services
Charles Schwab, a licensed bank, is among the largest brokers in the US. It offers a range of services including managing company 401(k) plans, providing standard accounts to retail investors, and offering self-directed IRAs. Additionally, this firm provides various banking services such as loans, checking accounts, and more.
When considering step by step, the fact remains that the high yield checking account offered by this bank is possibly one of the best options to utilize while traveling overseas. Unlike other banks, this account does not incur foreign transaction fees or monthly charges, and additionally ensures unlimited ATM rebate. As a result, it will refund ATM fees that can accumulate in the long run.
Charles Schwab does not provide as many investment options as Pensco or uDirect IRA, but it offers distinct services that set it apart from other brokerages.
TD Ameritrade and Merrill Edge
Common discount brokers that have traditional investments and banking services
TD Ameritrade and Merrill Edge are companies with a presence across the country that have physical branches and phone-based customer support. They also oversee corporate 401(k) accounts. While these companies do offer self-directed IRAs, they do not have the same range of alternative assets as Pensco or Equity Trust. Instead, their offerings include traditional investment products such as stocks, bonds, ETFs, and mutual funds. In addition, they provide attractive bonuses for new account holders and access to financial advisors.
Financial advisors have different fees and higher account balance requirements. TD Ameritrade has funds with lower expense ratios compared to Merrill Edge. Additionally, TD offers banking products in Canada as a result of Toronto Dominion’s significant ownership. Merrill Edge has a broader range of mutual funds. To learn more about Merrill Edge and TD Ameritrade, the reviews below provide detailed information.
Entrust Group
An established group that prevents fraud
Entrust Group, renowned for its self-directed IRA custodian services, is widely acknowledged as among the best. With a track record spanning more than 30 years, the company diligently screens investments to safeguard against fraudulent activities. This is particularly valuable since numerous scammers employ self-directed IRAs to conceal their fraudulent schemes. Additionally, Entrust provides an extensive range of alternative investment options, although it does not offer checkbook writing.
Equity Trust
A self-directed IRA that provides more hand-holding
Equity Trust, which has been established for many years, offers investors access to knowledgeable advisers who specialize in alternative assets, enabling them to effectively manage potential challenges. Equity Trust holds numerous unconventional assets, such as private loans, private equity, and currency. Although this custodian does not offer check-writing services, it ensures a transparent and cost-effective fee structure that provides investors with clear insight into their expenses.
PENSCO
Best self-directed IRA for foreign real estate
PENSCO has $16 billion assets under management and over 50,000 accounts, making it one of the largest brokers. Additionally, it has an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau and offers various alternative investments. The broker aids in connecting investors with distinct alternative assets such as private placements, commodities (such as oil and crops), and private commercial and residential real estate assets. Furthermore, it assists investors in investing in foreign real estate, which can be challenging due to the different property laws in each country. However, a disadvantage of this broker is the absence of check writing services.
Bottom line
To keep track of all retirement accounts can be overwhelming, so it is advisable to concentrate on the ones that are applicable to a particular situation. Self-directed IRAs share many similarities with Roth and Traditional IRAs, except they allow for the inclusion of non-traditional assets. These assets encompass real estate, private business stocks, and other high risk/high reward ventures. As self-directed IRAs have distinct regulations and criteria, it is crucial to select the appropriate custodian. This guide delved into the specifics of self-directed IRAs and evaluated the top self-directed IRA brokers.
Leave a Reply